Diocese of Florida announces plans for new bishop election after process of healing

[Episcopal News Service] The Diocese of Florida Standing Committee is calling for the election of a diocesan bishop, nearly two years after the last election was negated amid divisions within the diocese under the former bishop and churchwide concerns about the election process and the bishop-elect.

Florida’s standing committee announced March 31 that it has scheduled a special meeting of the Florida Diocesan Convention for June 14 to adopt a nominating process, rules and procedures for seeking and electing the diocese’s ninth bishop. The standing committee’s tentative timeline would allow for an election in late summer or early fall 2026 and the bishop-elect’s consecration in early 2027.

The announcement follows a period of healing and discernment among members of the Jacksonville-based diocese involving a series of conversations across difference. Those conversations, which are ongoing, have been facilitated by the Rt. Rev. Mary Gray-Reeves, the former Diocese of El Camino Real bishop who is trained in conflict mediation. The process was not intended specifically to enable a new bishop election, though diocesan leaders previously indicated healing would be necessary before a new election could be held.

“We feel like we’re ready. There’s been lots of conversations over the last year and a half or so,” the Rev. Sarah Minton, the standing committee president, said March 31 in an interview with Episcopal News Service. “It’s time. We are meant to operate with a bishop.”

The diocese has been without a diocesan bishop since the October 2023 retirement of former Florida Bishop John Howard, who had served for nearly 20 years. Howard, known as one of The Episcopal Church’s more theologically conservative bishops, had drawn criticism from more progressive leaders in the diocese, particularly for his resistance to LGBTQ+ inclusion.

Howard now faces potential disciplinary action under the church’s Title IV canons for alleged discrimination, as well as a separate complaint alleging financial impropriety. Those cases are scheduled to go before a hearing panel, starting April 30, unless an accord is reached with churchwide leaders beforehand.

Presiding Bishop Sean Rowe, who took office last November, said in a February statement he is attempting to negotiate a disciplinary accord “that promotes healing, repentance, forgiveness, restitution, justice, amendment of life and reconciliation,” citing canonical language. Such an agreement, if reached, also would need the approval of the Disciplinary Board for Bishops.

Under Howard, tensions in the diocese began rising to the surface in 2022 when the diocese twice tried to elect his successor. In both elections, the diocese chose the Rev. Charlie Holt as its next bishop, but those elections were successfully blocked by objections filed by some Florida clergy and lay leaders, leaving Florida unable to consecrate a new bishop. Holt has since become rector of St. Mark’s Episcopal Church in Jacksonville.

Gray-Reeves’ work with the Diocese of Florida has included multiple convocations, a clergy conference, a clergy day and a day of prayer, the standing committee said. In addition, retired Georgia Bishop Scott Benhase agreed to serve Florida as a part-time assisting bishop with help from retired New Jersey Bishop Chip Stokes.

In January 2024, Gray-Reeves released a summary of her initial listening sessions and dozens of letters lamenting a “culture of acrimony and distrust” in the diocese. Some letters raised concerns about diocesan leadership under Howard. Others identified perceived bias and exclusion relating to LGBTQ+ persons, as well as women and people of color.

“A few letters reflected upset and disappointment in the outcome of the [bishop] election process,” Gray-Reeves continued, both from those who thought Holt should have been consecrated and those who objected to his election. Holt had fallen short of receiving consent from the churchwide majorities of bishops and standing committees, as required by the church’s canons.

In September 2024, at the latest diocesan convention, some members backed a resolution urging the Florida Standing Committee to launch a new bishop search. That measure was tabled to allow more time for “further healing and strengthening.”

“The continued success of this process will reveal the best election timing to the Standing Committee,” the standing committee said at the time in a statement to ENS.

Minton told ENS this week that the additional time has given the standing committee more confidence that the diocese is ready now to seek a new bishop. She emphasized that concerns about the election process have been addressed with updates to the diocese’s canons and policies ensuring greater transparency.

Before the special convention on June 14, the diocese will release a draft of proposed rules and procedures, which will be debated and approved by delegates. This also will be the first time the diocese is following a new process for determining voting rolls. Canonically resident clergy who are active in Florida congregations automatically qualify to vote, while those without cure, such as retired clergy or those living outside the diocese, must register by April 15.

“As we enter this pivotal time for our diocese, may we be united in spirit and steadfast in prayer,” Minton said March 31 in her message to the diocese announcing the special convention. “We humbly ask that you join us in lifting up this initiative to the Lord, believing that he will lead us with wisdom and bless our work for his glory.”

– David Paulsen is a senior reporter and editor for Episcopal News Service based in Wisconsin. He can be reached at dpaulsen@episcopalchurch.org.